Skip to content
Pivot & Bloom
  • Services
  • Approach
  • About
  • Notes
  • Contact
Start a project

Notes.No. 2, November 2026
About a four-minute read

You’re paying the beige tax.

AI made average free, and looking like everyone else is getting expensive

Anyone can make a perfectly decent ad now. You type in a product and a vibe, and a minute later you have a clean layout and a headline that’s completely fine. Meta has been building toward a system where a brand hands over a product image and a budget and gets back a finished ad.1 Average used to take a team and a few rounds of revisions, and now it’s free.

My homepage says AI is welcome to the busywork but will never have taste, and I mean that as a business point. Once anyone can make average for free, average stops telling a customer anything about you. If a prompt could have made it, nobody’s going to remember it.

For a long time, polish was a signal. A glossy product shot meant somebody paid a photographer, so customers read polish as proof that a brand had money and planned to stick around. In 2004, Tim Ambler and Ann Hollier even measured it and found that ads that looked expensive were more persuasive, mostly because they made people think more highly of the brand.2 That signal stopped working once a generator could spit out the same glossy shot for free, because now polish doesn’t prove anybody spent a dime.

Free average also tends to make everything look alike. In a 2024 study, researchers gave some writers story ideas from an AI and left others on their own. The AI-assisted stories were rated more creative and better written, especially for the weakest writers, but they were also more similar to each other than the stories people wrote alone.3 The writers all got a little better and their stories got a little more alike, which is also a decent description of every feed right now.

Everyone has noticed, including Merriam-Webster, which made “slop” its 2025 word of the year and defined it as low-quality digital content churned out in bulk with AI.4 And Coca-Cola, a brand that basically owns holiday nostalgia, used AI to remake its “Holidays Are Coming” trucks two years in a row and got roasted online both times.5

All that sameness comes with a bill you could call the beige tax. When Nielsen and NCSolutions broke down where advertising’s sales lift comes from, the creative itself mattered as much as reach, targeting, timing and context combined, and weak creative leaned on the media to carry it.6 So when your ad looks like everyone else’s, the only way to get it noticed is to buy more of it, and Meta is very happy to sell you that.

Fig. 1.How the beige tax works. An illustration, not a dataset.

A prompt won’t hand you the unlikely choice, because generators are built to predict the most probable answer. The brands people remember made improbable choices on purpose.

  • Glossier=a shipping pouch people kept long after the lip balm ran out, in a pink that’s now a registered trademark.7
  • Graza=the squeeze bottle you suddenly started seeing in every cooking video on your feed.
  • Aesop=the hand soap that tells you everything about a restaurant before the food arrives.
  • Oatly=the only milk carton anyone has ever read for fun.

You remember every one of those because nobody would have predicted them.

“If a prompt could have made it, nobody’s going to remember it.”

Taste does have one problem, which is that it turns into a trend as soon as everyone copies it, and copying is now basically free too. Fashion managed to go beige without any help from AI. By 2018, Burberry, Balenciaga, Celine and Calvin Klein had all rolled out bold sans-serif logos so interchangeable that Hypebeast ran a whole story asking why every new fashion logo looked the same.8 Less than five years later, Burberry dug a knight logo from around 1901 back out of the archive and went back to a serif.9 If Burberry couldn’t make borrowed taste stick with an entire creative department, a prompt isn’t going to do it for you.

Next time you’re reviewing creative, ask:

  1. If we’d typed the brief into a generator, how different would this look?
  2. Which choices in this ad did someone actually make, and which came with the template?
  3. If a competitor ran it with their logo on it, would anyone notice?
And maybe most importantly

What’s in this that only we would have made?

So put your money on the choice a generator would never make, the weird, specific one somebody on your team has to fight for. It costs more up front, and it’s still cheaper than the beige tax.

End rant.

Does your marketing look like it came out of a prompt?

Send me what you’re putting out, and I’ll tell you which parts anyone could have generated.

Start a project See what I do

Sources

  1. Andrew Hutchinson, “Sociable: Meta reportedly expects to offer fully automated AI ads by 2026,” Marketing Dive, June 2, 2025, on reporting by The Wall Street Journal.
  2. Tim Ambler and E. Ann Hollier, “The Waste in Advertising Is the Part That Works,” Journal of Advertising Research 44, no. 4 (2004): 375–389.
  3. Anil R. Doshi and Oliver P. Hauser, “Generative AI enhances individual creativity but reduces the collective diversity of novel content,” Science Advances 10, no. 28 (2024).
  4. Merriam-Webster, “2025 Word of the Year: Slop,” December 14, 2025.
  5. John-Anthony Disotto, “Coca-Cola faces backlash again for missing the spirit of the holidays with another AI-slop ad,” TechRadar, November 4, 2025.
  6. Carl Marci, “Perspectives: Want a Successful Ad? Get Creative,” Nielsen, October 2017, on joint research by Nielsen and NCSolutions.
  7. The Fashion Law, “Glossier Has a Brand New Trademark Registration for its Pink Pouch,” August 25, 2020.
  8. Jack Stanley, “Why Do All New Fashion Logos Look the Same?” Hypebeast, September 20, 2018.
  9. James Parkes, “Burberry unveils ‘archive-inspired’ charging knight logo,” Dezeen, February 7, 2023.

You scrolled all the way down here, so we’d probably get along.

  • Services
  • Approach
  • About
  • Notes
  • LinkedIn
  • Poetry

Marketing is always mid-pivot. Stay in motion and you stay in bloom.

Pivot & Bloom
© 2026 Pivot & Bloom Media, LLCPrivacy Designed and built in a mid-century house just outside Denver, and set in Archivo and Familjen Grotesk. Denver
0
Skip to Content
Contact
PIVOT & BLOOM
Contact
PIVOT & BLOOM
Contact