Notes.No. 1, November 2026
About a four-minute read
Brand strategy is interpretation design.
A small brand rant, and a cognitive science rabbit hole
Brand perception is a distributed system, and it runs in the minds of your audience. You control your logo, your tagline and your campaigns. You control the very serious brand guide deck with the 50+ adjectives no one outside the company will ever read.
How people interpret all of it is not up to you.
Cognitive scientists call the mechanism underneath this conceptual blending, the way the mind fuses separate ideas into new meaning at the moment of perception.1 Applied to brands, people unconsciously merge your signals with their own experiences, biases and associations. Which is a fancy way of saying your brand is whatever people think it is, no matter what the deck says, and every customer is still going to run it through their own weird little internal filing system.
So does that mean branding is aimless chaos? Sometimes, yes, but not entirely, because even though you can’t control perception, you can shape the conditions it forms in.
A few brands have mastered this. They repeat their core attributes SO consistently, in so many contexts, that those attributes shape how people read every single thing they do. Think of them as anchors, and once they’re set, they do most of the work.
- Liquid Deathirreverence, anti-corporate, hydration as a joke you’re in on.
- Hims & Hersdestigmatization through millennial design, pharmacy as lifestyle brand.
- Crocsugly-cute, unbelievably comfortable, weirdly self-aware, you either get it or you don’t.
- Patagoniaexploration, durability, environmental responsibility.
None of these brands has to reintroduce itself every time it shows up.
The brain sorts what it sees through the filter it already has for a brand. That’s why a $32 Nike T-shirt feels athletic and a $720 Gucci T-shirt feels expensive, even though both are 100% cotton.2,3 Different story, different filter.
There’s a trade-off, though. The stronger the anchor, the harder it is to evolve, and if you shift too fast, you break the mental model people already have. Tropicana learned this the hard way in 2009, when it swapped its orange-with-a-straw carton for a minimalist glass of juice. Unit sales fell 20% in under two months, and six weeks after launch the old carton was on its way back.4,5 Fifteen years later it redesigned the bottle, and by October 2024 its sales had dropped 19%.5
So instead of asking “What are we saying?”, ask:
- What mental filter are people already using to interpret us?
- How strong is that filter?
- Are we reinforcing it, evolving it or accidentally fighting against it?
Are we asking one campaign to do the work of a brand system we never actually built?
Your audience receives your brand through memory, context, category norms, competitor noise, cultural associations, prior disappointment, personal taste and the general human tendency to make meaning out of literally everything, including fonts.
Which is why brand strategy is interpretation design. The best brands know what they want to say, and they understand the filter people are already using to hear it.
End rant.
Have a brand people keep reading the wrong way?
Send me what you’re putting out there and what people seem to hear instead, and I’ll tell you which filter they’re probably using.
Sources
- Annamma Joy, John F. Sherry Jr. and Jonathan Deschenes, “Conceptual blending in advertising,” Journal of Business Research 62 (2009): 39–49, building on Gilles Fauconnier and Mark Turner, The Way We Think (2002).
- Nike, “Nike Sportswear Club Men’s T-Shirt,” $32, 100% cotton. Price as of November 2026.
- Mytheresa, “Gucci logo cotton jersey T-shirt,” $720, 100% cotton. Price as of November 2026.
- Sasha Rogelberg, “Tropicana reignited a 15-year feud with customers over its packaging design,” Fortune, November 19, 2024.
- Nathaniel Meyersohn, “Tropicana fans are ditching the brand after a bottle redesign,” CNN, November 18, 2024.